Eye on Whatcom

Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

Remodeling Fairhaven Library Options
DJGray
Posted: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 8:02:57 AM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administrator , Member

Joined: 1/11/2008
Posts: 276
Location: Bellingham, WA
Given the complete waste of $232,299 paid to Thomas Hacker Architects for their consulting work on the proposed Bellingham Library rebuild, not to mention seven years of time, the Library Board has now proposed asking for two million for a remodel of the Fairhaven Library.

This may be a valid request, and that merits some investigation and consideration, however, once again, I am dumbfounded by a comment made by City Councilman Jack Weiss. Councilman Weiss, I'm assuming in an effort to build a sense of urgency, stated “It may be too late already," according to Sam Taylor of the Bellingham Herald.

Let's think this through.

First off, the quote is pulled out of context, leaving us to speculate on what it is too late for. Given the thrust of the story, I am taking this to mean that it may be too late to repair the building. The damage is so extensive that effective repairs cannot be made. With that assumption, I'll continue the analysis.

If it is too late already, then I'm most certainly opposed to throwing two million dollars toward a futile effort. It's too late. The building needs to be knocked down and replaced. Save the taxpayers' money for other projects where it is not too late. Perhaps the new water facility at Lake Whatcom?

However, if it is not too late already, and Councilman Weiss is simply overstating his case, then this overstatement impugns the integrity of the councilman and makes future statements vulnerable to questioning and non-belief since he has shown himself to be prone to exaggeration.

The third angle on this keys on the phrase "may be;" "It may be too late already." Well, before we dump two million dollars into this building, doesn't it behoove us to make that determination? If it is too late, then why spend money on a fruitless effort? By what line of reasoning would we even take one more step toward this remodeling/repair while the possibility that it is "too late" is still in question?






Mark Twain wrote:

A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is putting its shoes on.

  • Mark Twain


  • Baron Miller wrote:

    Grace ruins the idea that you are fully in charge.

  • Baron Miller



  • Stan Snapp
    Posted: Sunday, March 23, 2008 2:44:17 PM

    Rank: New Member
    Groups: Member

    Joined: 1/9/2008
    Posts: 51
    Location: Bellingham
    Damon,
    I think what Councilmember Weiss meant by "it may be too late already" is the construction season for patching and resurfacing stucco, which is the outside covering on the building. I'm not sure he's correct but it's a statement recognizing how long it takes for the City process to get a contractor on a site working from the time it's decided to do the work. I think the two million number is high. The building assessment from a couple of years back offered up three alternatives and sorted needed repairs into categories of structural urgency, convenience items and cosmetics. That's not the titles, I don't have that document any longer but that's my recollection on it. One thing that concerns me is that when that assessment was completed I expected that Public Works, that manages the building for the library department would initiate some immediate repairs and lay out a work plan for the rest. It wasn't talked about back then to do nothing until the recommendation could be rolled in total into the future bond. It was recognized that there wasn't enough funds in the regular budget to do all of the needed work and thus the prioritizing was completed and presented to the Library Board.
    With all do respect, the Library Board and our Librarian are doing their best to make very challenging decisions that are outside of their comfort zone and, in many cases their expertise. It's a good thing that Public Works manages these facilities because it's just not what library folks do best. Although I'm a bit sheepish that this building has been allowed to fall to the current state of disrepair. I expect that Council may decide to dip into reserves to address this immediate problem so we can get this building back good condition.
    I hope this helps and that I'm not held to specifics.
    DJGray
    Posted: Sunday, March 23, 2008 3:49:20 PM

    Rank: Administration
    Groups: Administrator , Member

    Joined: 1/11/2008
    Posts: 276
    Location: Bellingham, WA
    Herein lies the beauty of open discussions like this. You've thrown a fourth option on the table, and it goes way back to the beginning of my post. What is it too late for? You're saying you think Jack may have meant that it is too late for patching and resurfacing? If that's what he meant, then I'm left wondering how that can be, since we just moved into the first of Spring. If anything, the construction season will be picking up, not slowing down.

    I recognize you said you don't want to be held to specifics, and you're speculating as to what Jack meant just as I am, so your request is fair. We're all speculating and scratching our heads. If nothing else, Jack keeps things interesting.

    Wink

    As for the $2 million, I can't recall where I read it, but somewhere I read that the amount is about double what actually be required, and the $2 mill was requested in order to more easily roll the Fairhaven Branch remodel into the main branch rebuild. Sorry, I can't recall where I read that.



    Mark Twain wrote:

    A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is putting its shoes on.

  • Mark Twain


  • Baron Miller wrote:

    Grace ruins the idea that you are fully in charge.

  • Baron Miller



  • Stan Snapp
    Posted: Tuesday, April 01, 2008 5:49:42 AM

    Rank: New Member
    Groups: Member

    Joined: 1/9/2008
    Posts: 51
    Location: Bellingham
    Damon,
    I'm a week out of this discussion but I recall the building analysis included three priorities with the first having to do with immediate weather protection needs like parapet work, rotten window frame replacements, the area close to the building perimeter slopes towards the building instead of away which directs water where you don't want it. The next priority had to do with systems, the undersized electrical service and some furnace upgrades, and some stiffening of certain walls to increase earth quake shaking resistance, etc. The lowest priority, or third option, was things like removing the dropped ceiling's added in a remodel some years back and other cosmetic reorganization that would restore historical appearance but not improve functionality. My concern is that we've had that report for more than two years and when it was given at a library board meeting I sat there and watched the Public Works department representative say they could do some of the repairs right away to stop weather infiltration. I get that P. W. manages the facility but the Library Board has to make sure that work is looked after and we're now, two years later, being told that no work has been done. That leads us to an emergency request for a million dollar repair that should be half of that or less depending on the amount of work not done. Over a two year period they should have completed all or most all of the top priority items. That's my heart burn with this and I don't know why we didn't get that request at yesterday's meeting but it wasn't in our packet.
    DJGray
    Posted: Tuesday, April 01, 2008 7:12:16 AM

    Rank: Administration
    Groups: Administrator , Member

    Joined: 1/11/2008
    Posts: 276
    Location: Bellingham, WA
    Stan Snapp wrote:
    ...and we're now, two years later, being told that no work has been done. That leads us to an emergency request for a million dollar repair that should be half of that or less depending on the amount of work not done. Over a two year period they should have completed all or most all of the top priority items. That's my heart burn with this ...


    Stan,

    These are the kind of questions that need to be asked, and in all candor, these are the kinds of questions that were not being asked and which caused me to run for City Council. I'm very pleased that you are asking these questions. I'm confident we would not always reach the same conclusions. That is evident from our discussions here, but I'm just very pleased to see you are concerned that the money we spend is spent wisely, and that we are getting the best return for every dollar spent.

    Mark Twain wrote:

    A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is putting its shoes on.

  • Mark Twain


  • Baron Miller wrote:

    Grace ruins the idea that you are fully in charge.

  • Baron Miller



  • Users browsing this topic
    Guest


    Forum Jump
    You cannot post new topics in this forum.
    You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
    You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
    You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
    You cannot create polls in this forum.
    You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

    Main Forum RSS : RSS

    YAFPro Theme Created by Jaben Cargman (Tiny Gecko)
    Powered by Yet Another Forum.net version 1.9.1.8 (NET v2.0) - 3/28/2008
    Copyright © 2003-2008 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.